Saturday, October 29, 2011

Placer: Part 1



4140 Monteverde Dr
Lincoln, CA 95648
Total Loss: $594,600Percent Loss: 55.3%
Asking Price: $479,900
Bedrooms:5    Baths: 3    Sq. feet:5242

Listing History:
Down 61.6% from $1,250,000 On 2007-04-28
Down 24.9% from $639,000 On 2008-08-30
Down 16.5% from $575,000 On 2009-04-18
Down 14.3% from $560,000 On 2009-08-29
Down 14.3% from $559,900 On 2009-09-12
Down 13.7% from $555,900 On 2009-09-26
Down 13.5% from $554,900 On 2009-10-10
Down 11.1% from $540,000 On 2010-05-01
Down 5.9% from $510,000 On 2010-12-18

Days on market: 1885
# of Times Listed: 7

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2006-08-31 for $1,074,500

MLS# 11057440      Google Maps


3709 Stone Temple Ct
Rocklin, CA 95765
Total Loss: $514,000Percent Loss: 34.5%
Asking Price: $975,000
Bedrooms:5    Baths: 4    Sq. feet:5100

Listing History:
Down 42.3% from $1,690,000 On 2006-09-02
Down 35.0% from $1,499,000 On 2006-10-14
Down 38.5% from $1,585,000 On 2007-01-20
Down 40.0% from $1,625,000 On 2007-05-06
Down 39.0% from $1,599,000 On 2007-06-30
Down 18.0% from $1,189,000 On 2009-06-20
Down 13.6% from $1,129,000 On 2009-07-25
Down 9.7% from $1,080,000 On 2009-08-08
Down 1.5% from $990,000 On 2009-09-05
Down 2.0% from $995,000 On 2011-09-03

Days on market: 2207
# of Times Listed: 6

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2005-10-13 for $1,489,000

MLS# 11062975      Google Maps


1300 Crystal Hollow Ct
Lincoln, CA 95648
Total Loss: $395,000Percent Loss: 63.7%
Asking Price: $225,000
Bedrooms:3    Baths: 2    Sq. feet:2050

Listing History:
Down 54.0% from $489,000 On 2007-05-12
Down 53.0% from $479,000 On 2007-07-14
Down 49.9% from $449,000 On 2007-09-22
Down 46.3% from $419,000 On 2007-11-10
Down 43.6% from $399,000 On 2008-03-01
Down 35.5% from $349,000 On 2008-03-29

Days on market: 2160
# of Times Listed: 4

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2005-11-29 for $620,000

MLS# 11035601      Google Maps


1480 Bella Cir
Lincoln, CA 95648
Total Loss: $326,000Percent Loss: 35.2%
Asking Price: $599,000
Bedrooms:5    Baths: 3    Sq. feet:3587

Listing History:
Down 52.1% from $1,250,000 On 2007-07-21

Days on market: 1955
# of Times Listed: 3

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2005-03-31 for $741,500
Sold on 2006-06-22 for $925,000

MLS# 11041985      Google Maps


5375 Parkford Cir
Granite Bay, CA 95746
Total Loss: $295,000Percent Loss: 50.0%
Asking Price: $295,000
Bedrooms:4    Baths: 2    Sq. feet:2016

Listing History:
Down 55.2% from $659,000 On 2006-04-15
Down 51.2% from $605,000 On 2006-09-02
Down 53.8% from $639,000 On 2007-01-06
Down 53.2% from $629,900 On 2007-05-12
Down 52.8% from $624,900 On 2007-06-16
Down 50.8% from $599,000 On 2007-07-28
Down 15.5% from $349,000 On 2009-08-01
Down 16.4% from $352,800 On 2009-11-14
Down 22.0% from $378,000 On 2010-03-13

Days on market: 2279
# of Times Listed: 8

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2004-03-10 for $97,000
Sold on 2005-08-02 for $590,000

MLS# 11068381      Google Maps


5402 Butte Cir
Rocklin, CA 95765
Total Loss: $287,272Percent Loss: 43.7%
Asking Price: $369,900
Bedrooms:5    Baths: 3    Sq. feet:3175
Days on market: 138
# of Times Listed: 2

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2011-06-13 for $657,172
Likely REO

MLS# 11071588      Google Maps


1425 Grovewood Ln
Roseville, CA 95747
Total Loss: $259,000Percent Loss: 45.4%
Asking Price: $312,000
Bedrooms:5    Baths: 3    Sq. feet:3122

Listing History:
Up 4.0% from $300,000 On 2011-06-25

Days on market: 2355
# of Times Listed: 4

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2005-05-18 for $571,000

MLS# 11072494      Google Maps


103 Ohara Pl
Lincoln, CA 95648
Total Loss: $258,000Percent Loss: 55.7%
Asking Price: $205,000
Bedrooms:3    Baths: 2    Sq. feet:2107

Listing History:
Down 61.0% from $525,000 On 2006-04-15
Down 60.6% from $520,000 On 2006-04-21
Down 59.0% from $499,950 On 2006-05-12
Down 60.5% from $519,000 On 2006-06-30
Down 59.8% from $509,950 On 2006-07-22
Down 59.0% from $499,950 On 2006-08-05
Down 39.7% from $339,900 On 2008-01-12
Down 8.9% from $225,000 On 2011-03-26
Down 4.7% from $215,000 On 2011-04-09

Days on market: 2182
# of Times Listed: 6

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2005-11-07 for $463,000

MLS# 11021035      Google Maps


2828 Cardinal Dr
Lincoln, CA 95648
Total Loss: $255,000Percent Loss: 51.5%
Asking Price: $240,000
Bedrooms:4    Baths: 2    Sq. feet:2062

Listing History:
Down 46.6% from $449,500 On 2006-08-05
Down 46.1% from $444,900 On 2006-08-19
Down 44.8% from $435,000 On 2006-09-02
Down 42.0% from $414,000 On 2007-06-16
Down 39.8% from $399,000 On 2007-06-30
Down 36.7% from $379,000 On 2007-09-01
Up 4.3% from $230,000 On 2011-05-21

Days on market: 2277
# of Times Listed: 6

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2005-08-04 for $495,000

MLS# 11074632      Google Maps


3821 Northhaven Dr
Rocklin, CA 95677
Total Loss: $250,000Percent Loss: 53.2%
Asking Price: $220,000
Bedrooms:3    Baths: 3    Sq. feet:2122

Listing History:
Down 56.9% from $509,900 On 2006-05-12
Down 56.0% from $499,900 On 2006-06-22
Down 55.1% from $489,900 On 2006-08-05
Down 54.2% from $479,900 On 2006-08-19
Down 53.2% from $469,900 On 2006-09-30

Days on market: 2452
# of Times Listed: 5

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2004-09-29 for $395,500
Sold on 2005-02-10 for $470,000

MLS# 11063445      Google Maps


6335 Surfbird Ln
Rocklin, CA 95765
Total Loss: $230,000Percent Loss: 48.4%
Asking Price: $245,000
Bedrooms:4    Baths: 2    Sq. feet:2485

Listing History:
Down 50.6% from $495,888 On 2006-08-19
Down 49.5% from $484,888 On 2006-09-02
Down 47.9% from $469,950 On 2006-09-16

Days on market: 2586
# of Times Listed: 2

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2004-09-29 for $475,000

MLS# 11075743      Google Maps


934 Devonshire Ln
Lincoln, CA 95648
Total Loss: $225,500Percent Loss: 53.1%
Asking Price: $199,000
Bedrooms:4    Baths: 2    Sq. feet:2802

Listing History:
Down 60.1% from $499,000 On 2007-06-23
Down 59.8% from $495,000 On 2007-10-06

Days on market: 2283
# of Times Listed: 4

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2005-07-29 for $424,500

MLS# 11068809      Google Maps


3193 Amoruso Way
Roseville, CA 95747
Total Loss: $220,000Percent Loss: 41.1%
Asking Price: $315,000
Bedrooms:3    Baths: 3    Sq. feet:2252

Listing History:
Down 21.1% from $399,000 On 2011-02-26
Down 10.0% from $350,000 On 2011-04-09
Down 7.1% from $339,000 On 2011-07-23
Down 8.7% from $345,000 On 2011-08-13
Down 3.1% from $325,000 On 2011-08-20

Days on market: 1803
# of Times Listed: 2

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2006-11-21 for $535,000

MLS# 11014715      Google Maps


1279 Seymour Cir
Lincoln, CA 95648
Total Loss: $210,799Percent Loss: 54.6%
Asking Price: $175,000
Bedrooms:3    Baths: 2    Sq. feet:1857
Days on market: 229
# of Times Listed: 2

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2006-07-28 for $334,500
Sold on 2006-07-28 for $334,500
Sold on 2011-03-14 for $385,799

MLS# 11071948      Google Maps


288 Sawmill Ln
Lincoln, CA 95648
Total Loss: $210,100Percent Loss: 24.0%
Asking Price: $664,900
Bedrooms:3    Baths: 3    Sq. feet:3081

Listing History:
Down 28.1% from $925,000 On 2007-05-26
Down 24.4% from $879,000 On 2008-04-19
Down 22.6% from $859,000 On 2008-07-05
Down 21.7% from $849,000 On 2009-04-18
Down 16.8% from $799,000 On 2009-06-27
Down 14.6% from $779,000 On 2009-09-19
Down 8.8% from $729,000 On 2009-10-31
Down 9.4% from $733,995 On 2010-05-22
Down 7.5% from $719,000 On 2010-10-30
Down 4.9% from $699,000 On 2011-04-16
Down 4.3% from $695,000 On 2011-05-21
Down 2.9% from $685,000 On 2011-07-16

Days on market: 1821
# of Times Listed: 4

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2005-11-02 for $691,500
Sold on 2006-11-03 for $875,000

MLS# 10040139      Google Maps


3291 Garden Bar Rd
Lincoln, CA 95648
Total Loss: $205,299Percent Loss: 52.6%
Asking Price: $184,900
Bedrooms:2    Baths: 1    Sq. feet:1647
Days on market: 492
# of Times Listed: 2

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2010-06-24 for $390,199

MLS# 11065066      Google Maps


9410 Pinehurst Dr
Roseville, CA 95747
Total Loss: $195,409Percent Loss: 32.9%
Asking Price: $399,000
Bedrooms:3    Baths: 3    Sq. feet:3982
Days on market: 2535
# of Times Listed: 2

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2004-11-19 for $594,409

MLS# 11011788      Google Maps


3837 Sweetwater Dr
Rocklin, CA 95677
Total Loss: $195,000Percent Loss: 37.9%
Asking Price: $320,000
Bedrooms:3    Baths: 3    Sq. feet:2347

Listing History:
Down 43.4% from $565,000 On 2006-06-09
Down 39.6% from $529,950 On 2006-09-09
Down 34.7% from $489,950 On 2006-09-23
Down 33.3% from $479,950 On 2006-10-07
Down 30.4% from $459,950 On 2006-10-21
Down 27.3% from $439,950 On 2006-11-04
Down 35.4% from $495,000 On 2007-11-03
Down 34.6% from $489,000 On 2007-11-10
Down 32.6% from $475,000 On 2007-11-24

Days on market: 2167
# of Times Listed: 6

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2005-11-22 for $515,000

MLS# 11045035      Google Maps


1676 Markdale Ln
Lincoln, CA 95648
Total Loss: $194,000Percent Loss: 43.4%
Asking Price: $253,000
Bedrooms:4    Baths: 4    Sq. feet:3161

Listing History:
Down 41.1% from $429,900 On 2008-10-11

Days on market: 1774
# of Times Listed: 3

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2006-12-20 for $447,000

MLS# 11073459      Google Maps


1817 Sunstone Dr
Roseville, CA 95747
Total Loss: $194,000Percent Loss: 50.5%
Asking Price: $190,000
Bedrooms:3    Baths: 2    Sq. feet:1298

Listing History:
Down 51.9% from $395,000 On 2006-04-21
Down 15.6% from $225,000 On 2011-07-02
Down 13.6% from $220,000 On 2011-07-09
Down 9.5% from $210,000 On 2011-07-23
Down 4.5% from $199,000 On 2011-08-06

Days on market: 2381
# of Times Listed: 3

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2005-04-22 for $384,000

MLS# 11048280      Google Maps


2664 Moonbeam Ter
Meadow Vista, CA 95722
Total Loss: $189,032Percent Loss: 51.2%
Asking Price: $179,900
Bedrooms:2    Baths: 1    Sq. feet:1409

Listing History:
Down 56.9% from $417,000 On 2006-06-22
Down 56.1% from $410,000 On 2006-07-28
Down 54.5% from $395,000 On 2006-08-26

Days on market: 149
# of Times Listed: 3

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2011-06-02 for $368,932
Likely REO

MLS# 11073749      Google Maps


502 Diamond Oaks Rd
Roseville, CA 95678
Total Loss: $185,050Percent Loss: 48.1%
Asking Price: $199,950
Bedrooms:4    Baths: 3    Sq. feet:1772

Listing History:
Down 58.3% from $479,000 On 2006-04-21

Days on market: 2536
# of Times Listed: 2

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2004-11-18 for $385,000

MLS# 11075687      Google Maps


5652 Miners Cir
Rocklin, CA 95765
Total Loss: $182,500Percent Loss: 52.5%
Asking Price: $165,000
Bedrooms:3    Baths: 2    Sq. feet:1251

Listing History:
Down 54.2% from $359,900 On 2006-08-19
Down 53.3% from $353,000 On 2006-09-02
Down 52.7% from $349,000 On 2006-09-16
Down 40.0% from $275,000 On 2008-10-18
Down 37.5% from $264,000 On 2008-11-01
Down 26.3% from $224,000 On 2010-05-15
Down 22.9% from $214,000 On 2010-06-26
Down 12.7% from $189,000 On 2010-07-24
Down 22.9% from $214,000 On 2010-09-04
Down 17.1% from $199,000 On 2010-09-25
Down 21.4% from $210,000 On 2011-01-08
Down 8.3% from $180,000 On 2011-01-29
Down 17.1% from $199,000 On 2011-04-23
Down 10.8% from $185,000 On 2011-05-14
Down 5.7% from $175,000 On 2011-07-16

Days on market: 1828
# of Times Listed: 4

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2003-10-24 for $288,000
Sold on 2006-10-27 for $347,500

MLS# 10037266      Google Maps


5419 2nd St
Rocklin, CA 95677
Total Loss: $178,000Percent Loss: 44.0%
Asking Price: $227,000
Bedrooms:4    Baths: 3    Sq. feet:1909

Listing History:
Down 53.2% from $485,000 On 2006-06-01
Down 52.2% from $475,000 On 2006-07-08
Down 44.0% from $405,000 On 2007-04-28
Down 30.2% from $325,000 On 2008-08-09
Down 8.8% from $249,000 On 2011-04-30
Down 5.0% from $239,000 On 2011-05-21

Days on market: 1605
# of Times Listed: 6

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2007-06-07 for $405,000

MLS# 11031429      Google Maps


6115 Lords Way
Foresthill, CA 95631
Total Loss: $177,728Percent Loss: 53.4%
Asking Price: $154,900
Bedrooms:3    Baths: 2    Sq. feet:1512

Listing History:
Up 2.6% from $151,000 On 2010-06-05
Down 18.0% from $189,000 On 2011-06-18
Down 13.9% from $179,900 On 2011-07-09
Down 8.9% from $170,100 On 2011-09-10

Days on market: 313
# of Times Listed: 3

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2010-12-20 for $332,628

MLS# 11044263      Google Maps


7585 Millport Dr
Roseville, CA 95678
Total Loss: $175,000Percent Loss: 40.7%
Asking Price: $255,000
Bedrooms:3    Baths: 2    Sq. feet:1630

Listing History:
Down 45.6% from $469,000 On 2006-06-01
Down 45.0% from $464,000 On 2006-06-09
Down 43.9% from $454,900 On 2006-06-16
Down 43.2% from $448,900 On 2006-06-22
Down 42.0% from $439,900 On 2006-06-30
Down 36.1% from $399,000 On 2007-05-19
Down 35.4% from $394,900 On 2007-06-09

Days on market: 1905
# of Times Listed: 4

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2005-09-07 for $496,000
Sold on 2006-08-11 for $430,000
Sold on 2006-08-11 for $430,000

MLS# 11076894      Google Maps


1031 Treasure Ln
Roseville, CA 95678
Total Loss: $160,100Percent Loss: 45.7%
Asking Price: $189,900
Bedrooms:4    Baths: 2    Sq. feet:1510
Days on market: 718
# of Times Listed: 2

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2005-07-28 for $410,000
Sold on 2009-11-10 for $350,000

MLS# 11018506      Google Maps


1187 Kensington Ln
Lincoln, CA 95648
Total Loss: $152,500Percent Loss: 45.2%
Asking Price: $185,000
Bedrooms:3    Baths: 2    Sq. feet:1916

Listing History:
Down 31.5% from $269,900 On 2008-04-12

Days on market: 1433
# of Times Listed: 2

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2005-02-24 for $414,500
Sold on 2007-11-26 for $337,500

MLS# 11075846      Google Maps


4404 Newland Heights Ct
Rocklin, CA 95765
Total Loss: $150,070Percent Loss: 34.9%
Asking Price: $279,930
Bedrooms:2    Baths: 2    Sq. feet:1663

Listing History:
Up 12.0% from $249,900 On 2011-05-14
Up 21.8% from $229,900 On 2011-06-04

Days on market: 2175
# of Times Listed: 3

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2005-11-14 for $430,000

MLS# 11067606      Google Maps


2196 Griffith Ln
Penryn, CA 95663
Total Loss: $145,400Percent Loss: 57.5%
Asking Price: $107,600
Bedrooms:2    Baths: 1    Sq. feet:1256

Listing History:
Down 72.3% from $389,000 On 2006-08-26

Days on market: 1681
# of Times Listed: 2

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2007-03-23 for $253,000

MLS# 11076423      Google Maps


1665 Markdale Ln
Lincoln, CA 95648
Total Loss: $145,100Percent Loss: 40.3%
Asking Price: $214,900
Bedrooms:4    Baths: 2    Sq. feet:2301

Listing History:
Down 33.9% from $325,000 On 2008-03-01
Down 27.2% from $295,000 On 2008-05-03

Days on market: 1738
# of Times Listed: 3

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2007-01-25 for $360,000

MLS# 11043320      Google Maps


1476 Zinnia Way
Roseville, CA 95747
Total Loss: $140,693Percent Loss: 39.6%
Asking Price: $215,000
Bedrooms:3    Baths: 2    Sq. feet:1513
Days on market: 502
# of Times Listed: 2

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2004-12-30 for $405,000
Sold on 2010-06-14 for $355,693

MLS# 11064371      Google Maps


1540 Midford Ln
Lincoln, CA 95648
Total Loss: $130,550Percent Loss: 34.3%
Asking Price: $249,900
Bedrooms:4    Baths: 3    Sq. feet:2990

Listing History:
Down 9.1% from $275,000 On 2009-08-01
Down 4.3% from $261,000 On 2009-08-08
Down 16.7% from $299,900 On 2010-06-05
Down 12.3% from $284,900 On 2010-07-17

Days on market: 529
# of Times Listed: 4

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2007-11-15 for $380,000
Sold on 2010-01-07 for $280,000
Sold on 2010-05-18 for $380,450

MLS# 11073037      Google Maps


105 Talmont Cir
Roseville, CA 95678
Total Loss: $129,450Percent Loss: 36.5%
Asking Price: $225,550
Bedrooms:3    Baths: 2    Sq. feet:1624
Days on market: 568
# of Times Listed: 3

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2010-04-09 for $355,000

MLS# 11071294      Google Maps


6460 Longridge Ct
Foresthill, CA 95631
Total Loss: $126,000Percent Loss: 30.4%
Asking Price: $289,000
Bedrooms:4    Baths: 3    Sq. feet:4012

Listing History:
Down 62.2% from $765,000 On 2006-05-12
Down 59.6% from $715,000 On 2006-09-30
Down 55.5% from $649,999 On 2007-07-28
Down 51.8% from $599,999 On 2007-09-01
Down 47.0% from $545,000 On 2007-12-22
Down 9.4% from $319,000 On 2011-09-10

Days on market: 2696
# of Times Listed: 6

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2004-06-11 for $415,000

MLS# 10086311      Google Maps


116 Franklin St
Roseville, CA 95678
Total Loss: $115,870Percent Loss: 53.9%
Asking Price: $99,000
Bedrooms:3    Baths: 1    Sq. feet:1752
Days on market: 163
# of Times Listed: 2

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2011-05-19 for $214,870
Likely REO

MLS# 11073515      Google Maps


101 Paizano Ct
Roseville, CA 95661
Total Loss: $115,500Percent Loss: 16.9%
Asking Price: $569,500
Bedrooms:5    Baths: 3    Sq. feet:4064

Listing History:
Down 24.0% from $749,000 On 2007-12-08
Down 21.9% from $729,000 On 2008-01-19
Up 14.1% from $499,000 On 2009-08-22

Days on market: 1362
# of Times Listed: 3

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2008-02-05 for $685,000

MLS# 11077153      Google Maps


5755 11th St
Sheridan, CA 95681
Total Loss: $113,000Percent Loss: 51.8%
Asking Price: $105,000
Bedrooms:3    Baths: 1    Sq. feet:1064

Listing History:
Down 57.8% from $248,600 On 2007-03-10
Down 44.7% from $190,000 On 2009-03-07
Down 43.2% from $185,000 On 2010-02-27
Down 34.4% from $160,000 On 2010-08-28
Down 30.0% from $150,000 On 2011-01-15
Down 12.5% from $120,000 On 2011-02-26

Days on market: 1835
# of Times Listed: 5

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2005-09-09 for $250,000
Sold on 2006-10-20 for $218,000

MLS# 11003459      Google Maps


2209 Wild Plains Cir
Rocklin, CA 95765
Total Loss: $106,000Percent Loss: 22.8%
Asking Price: $359,000
Bedrooms:3    Baths: 3    Sq. feet:2738

Listing History:
Down 28.1% from $499,000 On 2009-01-10
Down 26.0% from $485,000 On 2009-01-24
Down 23.5% from $469,000 On 2009-03-21
Down 21.8% from $459,000 On 2009-06-27
Down 20.2% from $449,900 On 2010-06-26
Down 18.4% from $439,900 On 2010-07-31
Down 7.7% from $389,000 On 2011-08-20
Down 4.3% from $375,000 On 2011-09-03

Days on market: 1184
# of Times Listed: 4

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2008-08-01 for $465,000

MLS# 11060079      Google Maps


1201 Impressionist Loop
Roseville, CA 95747
Total Loss: $106,000Percent Loss: 34.8%
Asking Price: $199,000
Bedrooms:4    Baths: 2    Sq. feet:1750

Listing History:
Down 17.0% from $239,900 On 2010-06-26
Down 8.7% from $217,900 On 2010-07-17
Down 5.7% from $211,000 On 2011-05-21
Down 2.0% from $203,000 On 2011-06-18

Days on market: 1094
# of Times Listed: 3

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2008-10-30 for $305,000

MLS# 11046424      Google Maps


500 Copperwood Ct
Lincoln, CA 95648
Total Loss: $103,711Percent Loss: 32.1%
Asking Price: $219,000
Bedrooms:3    Baths: 2    Sq. feet:1655
Days on market: 317
# of Times Listed: 1

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2003-08-01 for $289,500
Sold on 2010-12-16 for $322,711

MLS# 11076929      Google Maps


323 Knorr Swiss Ln
Colfax, CA 95713
Total Loss: $93,875Percent Loss: 48.5%
Asking Price: $99,500
Bedrooms:2    Baths: 2    Sq. feet:1100

Listing History:
Down 9.5% from $110,000 On 2011-07-30

Days on market: 1277
# of Times Listed: 2

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2004-06-25 for $250,000
Sold on 2008-04-30 for $193,375

MLS# 11053864      Google Maps


3631 Galena Dr
Auburn, CA 95602
Total Loss: $92,709Percent Loss: 64.5%
Asking Price: $51,000
Bedrooms:2    Baths: 1    Sq. feet:922
Days on market: 1682
# of Times Listed: 1

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2007-03-22 for $143,709

MLS# 11076764      Google Maps


330 Berkeley Ave
Roseville, CA 95678
Total Loss: $91,525Percent Loss: 35.0%
Asking Price: $169,900
Bedrooms:3    Baths: 2    Sq. feet:1669

Listing History:
Down 5.6% from $180,000 On 2011-09-03

Days on market: 151
# of Times Listed: 2

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2011-05-31 for $261,425
Likely REO

MLS# 11063968      Google Maps


24160 Main St
Foresthill, CA 95631
Total Loss: $82,308Percent Loss: 30.8%
Asking Price: $184,900
Bedrooms:3    Baths: 2    Sq. feet:1800

Listing History:
Down 9.8% from $204,900 On 2011-08-20
Down 2.6% from $189,900 On 2011-09-24

Days on market: 151
# of Times Listed: 2

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2011-05-31 for $267,208
Likely REO

MLS# 11059450      Google Maps


412 Main St
Roseville, CA 95678
Total Loss: $81,000Percent Loss: 32.4%
Asking Price: $169,000
Bedrooms:3    Baths: 1    Sq. feet:1298

Listing History:
Down 51.7% from $350,000 On 2007-08-25

Days on market: 1614
# of Times Listed: 3

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2007-05-29 for $250,000

MLS# 11018010      Google Maps


6129 Cameo Dr
Rocklin, CA 95677
Total Loss: $72,890Percent Loss: 20.7%
Asking Price: $279,900
Bedrooms:4    Baths: 3    Sq. feet:2509
Days on market: 150
# of Times Listed: 2

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2011-06-01 for $352,790
Likely REO

MLS# 11074036      Google Maps


2698 Lindbergh Ln
Lincoln, CA 95648
Total Loss: $70,000Percent Loss: 31.1%
Asking Price: $155,000
Bedrooms:3    Baths: 2    Sq. feet:1053
Days on market: 605
# of Times Listed: 2

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2010-03-03 for $225,000

MLS# 11060634      Google Maps


1865 Loring Ln
Lincoln, CA 95648
Total Loss: $64,000Percent Loss: 19.8%
Asking Price: $260,000
Bedrooms:5    Baths: 4    Sq. feet:3179

Listing History:
Down 24.6% from $344,900 On 2008-10-18
Up 6.1% from $245,000 On 2011-06-18

Days on market: 1179
# of Times Listed: 3

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2008-08-06 for $324,000

MLS# 11041669      Google Maps


1025 Marseille Ln
Roseville, CA 95747
Total Loss: $61,100Percent Loss: 20.0%
Asking Price: $244,900
Bedrooms:2    Baths: 2    Sq. feet:1163

Listing History:
Down 18.1% from $299,000 On 2010-08-07
Down 16.7% from $294,000 On 2010-08-14
Down 13.8% from $284,000 On 2010-09-18
Down 12.2% from $279,000 On 2010-10-16
Down 9.0% from $269,000 On 2010-11-13
Down 7.2% from $264,000 On 2010-12-04
Down 5.4% from $259,000 On 2011-01-15
Down 5.1% from $258,000 On 2011-02-26

Days on market: 849
# of Times Listed: 2

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2009-07-02 for $306,000

MLS# 11075701      Google Maps


1550 Swallowview Dr
Lincoln, CA 95648
Total Loss: $57,000Percent Loss: 23.3%
Asking Price: $188,000
Bedrooms:3    Baths: 2    Sq. feet:1530

Listing History:
Down 41.2% from $320,000 On 2008-01-26
Down 37.3% from $300,000 On 2008-02-02
Down 35.2% from $290,000 On 2008-02-23
Down 32.9% from $280,000 On 2008-03-08
Down 30.4% from $270,000 On 2008-03-22
Down 32.9% from $280,000 On 2008-03-29
Down 21.6% from $239,900 On 2008-09-27
Down 37.3% from $299,999 On 2010-08-07

Days on market: 1072
# of Times Listed: 5

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2005-03-09 for $398,000
Sold on 2008-11-21 for $245,000

MLS# 11011266      Google Maps


1123 Windermere Ave
Roseville, CA 95678
Total Loss: $55,000Percent Loss: 23.9%
Asking Price: $175,000
Bedrooms:4    Baths: 2    Sq. feet:1400

Listing History:
Down 26.3% from $237,500 On 2009-06-27
Down 23.2% from $227,995 On 2009-07-11

Days on market: 774
# of Times Listed: 3

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2009-09-15 for $230,000

MLS# 11020778      Google Maps


11316 Bosal Cir
Auburn, CA 95603
Total Loss: $48,500Percent Loss: 15.6%
Asking Price: $262,500
Bedrooms:3    Baths: 2    Sq. feet:1910

Listing History:
Down 22.6% from $339,000 On 2010-08-21
Down 11.0% from $295,000 On 2011-05-21
Down 7.7% from $284,500 On 2011-08-06
Down 4.4% from $274,500 On 2011-08-20

Days on market: 605
# of Times Listed: 3

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2010-03-03 for $311,000

MLS# 11036980      Google Maps


1611 Ashford Dr
Roseville, CA 95661
Total Loss: $47,198Percent Loss: 17.9%
Asking Price: $216,000
Bedrooms:2    Baths: 2    Sq. feet:1304
Days on market: 324
# of Times Listed: 1

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2008-01-03 for $295,000
Sold on 2010-12-09 for $263,198

MLS# 11076052      Google Maps


1775 El Camino Verde Dr
Lincoln, CA 95648
Total Loss: $47,000Percent Loss: 17.6%
Asking Price: $220,000
Bedrooms:4    Baths: 3    Sq. feet:2291

Listing History:
Down 15.0% from $258,900 On 2009-07-11

Days on market: 787
# of Times Listed: 3

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2009-06-04 for $265,000
Sold on 2009-09-02 for $267,000

MLS# 11054964      Google Maps


6315 Hemlock Way
Rocklin, CA 95677
Total Loss: $42,059Percent Loss: 17.0%
Asking Price: $205,900
Bedrooms:5    Baths: 2    Sq. feet:2840

Listing History:
Up 2.1% from $201,750 On 2011-08-06

Days on market: 353
# of Times Listed: 2

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2010-11-10 for $247,959

MLS# 11055614      Google Maps


9056 King Rd
Loomis, CA 95650
Total Loss: $41,989Percent Loss: 14.5%
Asking Price: $247,200
Bedrooms:2    Baths: 2    Sq. feet:1425

Listing History:
Down 45.1% from $450,000 On 2010-12-11
Down 41.8% from $425,000 On 2011-01-15
Down 38.0% from $399,000 On 2011-01-22
Down 36.6% from $390,000 On 2011-01-29

Days on market: 835
# of Times Listed: 3

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2003-08-18 for $390,000
Sold on 2009-07-16 for $289,189

MLS# 11073699      Google Maps


2604 Woodfield Way
Roseville, CA 95747
Total Loss: $41,000Percent Loss: 15.8%
Asking Price: $219,000
Bedrooms:4    Baths: 2    Sq. feet:1673

Listing History:
Down 24.5% from $290,000 On 2010-07-03
Down 21.5% from $279,000 On 2010-07-17
Down 18.3% from $268,000 On 2010-07-31
Down 20.7% from $276,000 On 2011-03-05
Down 19.2% from $271,000 On 2011-04-16
Down 12.0% from $249,000 On 2011-05-07
Down 4.4% from $229,000 On 2011-05-14

Days on market: 935
# of Times Listed: 3

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2009-04-07 for $260,000

MLS# 11014718      Google Maps


540 Patina Ct
Roseville, CA 95747
Total Loss: $40,100Percent Loss: 9.3%
Asking Price: $389,900
Bedrooms:5    Baths: 3    Sq. feet:2606

Listing History:
Down 9.3% from $429,990 On 2009-04-18
Down 6.0% from $414,900 On 2011-04-02
Down 1.0% from $394,000 On 2011-09-03

Days on market: 801
# of Times Listed: 4

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2009-08-19 for $430,000

MLS# 11063057      Google Maps


2910 Twin Creeks Ln
Rocklin, CA 95677
Total Loss: $40,100Percent Loss: 21.1%
Asking Price: $149,900
Bedrooms:3    Baths: 2    Sq. feet:1556

Listing History:
Down 60.0% from $375,000 On 2006-07-15
Down 57.2% from $349,900 On 2006-08-14
Down 53.9% from $325,000 On 2006-11-04
Down 50.0% from $299,990 On 2007-01-20
Down 43.4% from $265,000 On 2008-10-04
Down 33.4% from $225,000 On 2008-10-18
Down 23.1% from $195,000 On 2009-02-14
Down 11.3% from $169,000 On 2011-07-16
Down 9.2% from $165,000 On 2011-07-30
Down 5.7% from $159,000 On 2011-08-06

Days on market: 809
# of Times Listed: 5

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2007-02-15 for $311,000
Sold on 2009-08-11 for $190,000

MLS# 11050400      Google Maps


1105 Creek Ridge Ct
Roseville, CA 95747
Total Loss: $36,209Percent Loss: 11.8%
Asking Price: $269,990
Bedrooms:3    Baths: 2    Sq. feet:2038

Listing History:
Down 1.8% from $275,000 On 2011-04-30
Up 8.0% from $250,000 On 2011-05-14
Down 14.3% from $314,900 On 2011-09-24

Days on market: 151
# of Times Listed: 3

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2004-04-16 for $420,000
Sold on 2011-05-31 for $306,199
Likely REO

MLS# 11067560      Google Maps


630 Alta Ravine Rd
Alta, CA 95701
Total Loss: $35,300Percent Loss: 30.6%
Asking Price: $79,900
Bedrooms:3    Baths: 2    Sq. feet:1560

Listing History:
Down 20.0% from $99,900 On 2011-06-18
Down 18.4% from $97,900 On 2011-07-23
Down 11.1% from $89,900 On 2011-08-27
Down 5.9% from $84,900 On 2011-10-01

Days on market: 313
# of Times Listed: 2

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2010-01-26 for $300,000
Sold on 2010-12-20 for $115,200

MLS# 11044543      Google Maps


920 Machty Ct
Auburn, CA 95603
Total Loss: $31,100Percent Loss: 5.9%
Asking Price: $499,000
Bedrooms:5    Baths: 3    Sq. feet:3638
Days on market: 375
# of Times Listed: 2

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2010-10-19 for $530,100

MLS# 11046133      Google Maps


5408 Havenhurst Cir
Rocklin, CA 95677
Total Loss: $30,100Percent Loss: 13.7%
Asking Price: $189,900
Bedrooms:3    Baths: 2    Sq. feet:1144

Listing History:
Down 13.7% from $220,000 On 2009-05-09
Up 8.5% from $175,000 On 2009-05-16
Down 17.4% from $229,950 On 2009-09-05

Days on market: 708
# of Times Listed: 4

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2003-12-26 for $264,000
Sold on 2009-09-15 for $160,000
Sold on 2009-09-15 for $160,000
Sold on 2009-11-20 for $220,000

MLS# 11051938      Google Maps


6200 Flamingo Way
Rocklin, CA 95765
Total Loss: $30,000Percent Loss: 12.0%
Asking Price: $220,000
Bedrooms:3    Baths: 2    Sq. feet:1860

Listing History:
Down 48.2% from $425,000 On 2007-07-21
Down 46.0% from $407,500 On 2007-08-11
Down 41.4% from $375,500 On 2007-08-18
Down 37.1% from $350,000 On 2007-09-22
Down 32.3% from $325,000 On 2007-11-17
Down 26.4% from $299,000 On 2008-04-05
Down 26.1% from $297,500 On 2008-11-29
Down 20.7% from $277,500 On 2008-12-13
Down 17.1% from $265,500 On 2009-01-17
Down 17.0% from $265,000 On 2011-01-29
Down 12.0% from $250,000 On 2011-02-12
Down 6.4% from $235,000 On 2011-02-26

Days on market: 935
# of Times Listed: 4

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2004-09-03 for $402,500
Sold on 2009-04-07 for $250,000

MLS# 11007724      Google Maps


5155 2nd St
Rocklin, CA 95677
Total Loss: $28,100Percent Loss: 29.3%
Asking Price: $67,900
Bedrooms:2    Baths: 1    Sq. feet:488

Listing History:
Down 54.3% from $148,500 On 2009-06-20
Down 51.0% from $138,500 On 2009-06-27
Down 49.1% from $133,500 On 2009-07-25
Down 24.5% from $89,900 On 2010-04-03
Down 31.3% from $98,900 On 2010-09-18
Down 30.7% from $98,000 On 2010-10-16
Down 30.6% from $97,900 On 2010-10-30
Down 30.6% from $97,800 On 2010-11-13
Down 29.9% from $96,800 On 2011-01-22
Down 29.6% from $96,500 On 2011-01-29
Down 29.5% from $96,300 On 2011-02-05
Down 28.8% from $95,300 On 2011-02-12
Down 28.7% from $95,200 On 2011-02-19

Days on market: 547
# of Times Listed: 5

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2009-11-17 for $65,000
Sold on 2010-04-30 for $96,000

MLS# 11073333      Google Maps


2200 Trimstone Way
Roseville, CA 95747
Total Loss: $28,000Percent Loss: 9.6%
Asking Price: $265,000
Bedrooms:3    Baths: 2    Sq. feet:2002

Listing History:
Down 9.1% from $291,459 On 2009-10-03
Down 3.6% from $275,000 On 2011-09-10

Days on market: 703
# of Times Listed: 3

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2009-11-25 for $293,000

MLS# 11064905      Google Maps


6208 Lonetree Blvd
Rocklin, CA 95765
Total Loss: $27,500Percent Loss: 14.9%
Asking Price: $157,000
Bedrooms:3    Baths: 2    Sq. feet:1307

Listing History:
Down 26.6% from $214,000 On 2010-07-10
Down 24.9% from $209,000 On 2010-07-17
Down 21.1% from $199,000 On 2010-07-31
Down 20.3% from $197,000 On 2010-08-07
Down 17.2% from $189,500 On 2010-08-14
Down 15.1% from $185,000 On 2010-09-04
Down 15.1% from $184,999 On 2010-09-18
Down 7.1% from $169,000 On 2011-03-19

Days on market: 799
# of Times Listed: 3

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2009-08-21 for $184,500

MLS# 11018781      Google Maps


117 Snapdragon Pl
Lincoln, CA 95648
Total Loss: $27,500Percent Loss: 5.2%
Asking Price: $499,000
Bedrooms:2    Baths: 2    Sq. feet:2831

Listing History:
Down 40.5% from $839,000 On 2007-11-17
Down 40.2% from $834,900 On 2008-01-12
Down 35.6% from $774,900 On 2008-08-02
Down 34.3% from $759,900 On 2008-10-25
Down 32.4% from $737,900 On 2009-01-17
Down 30.6% from $719,000 On 2009-04-11
Down 29.7% from $709,900 On 2009-06-06
Down 27.7% from $689,900 On 2009-06-20
Down 7.4% from $539,000 On 2011-09-10

Days on market: 186
# of Times Listed: 6

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2006-02-16 for $711,000
Sold on 2011-04-26 for $526,500

MLS# 11064797      Google Maps


1401 Indiana Way
Rocklin, CA 95765
Total Loss: $22,500Percent Loss: 10.1%
Asking Price: $200,000
Bedrooms:3    Baths: 2    Sq. feet:1658

Listing History:
Down 42.0% from $345,000 On 2007-06-16
Down 11.1% from $225,000 On 2009-01-24

Days on market: 911
# of Times Listed: 5

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2005-10-07 for $395,000
Sold on 2009-05-01 for $222,500

MLS# 11019215      Google Maps


5645 Prosperity Ct
Foresthill, CA 95631
Total Loss: $19,500Percent Loss: 13.5%
Asking Price: $124,500
Bedrooms:3    Baths: 2    Sq. feet:1248

Listing History:
Down 57.8% from $295,000 On 2008-07-26
Down 3.7% from $129,300 On 2011-10-01

Days on market: 185
# of Times Listed: 3

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2011-04-27 for $144,000

MLS# 11070115      Google Maps


5008 High St
Rocklin, CA 95677
Total Loss: $13,100Percent Loss: 7.0%
Asking Price: $174,900
Bedrooms:2    Baths: 2    Sq. feet:1014

Listing History:
Down 20.3% from $219,500 On 2010-03-06
Down 16.5% from $209,500 On 2010-03-13
Down 16.5% from $209,495 On 2010-03-20
Down 14.7% from $204,950 On 2010-03-27
Down 2.8% from $180,000 On 2011-10-08
Down 2.6% from $179,500 On 2011-10-15

Days on market: 533
# of Times Listed: 3

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2010-05-14 for $188,000

MLS# 11072366      Google Maps


133 Pine St
Colfax, CA 95713
Total Loss: $10,500Percent Loss: 4.5%
Asking Price: $224,500
Bedrooms:3    Baths: 2    Sq. feet:1387

Listing History:
Down 4.5% from $235,000 On 2009-02-28
Down 6.1% from $239,000 On 2011-02-26
Down 2.0% from $229,000 On 2011-04-30

Days on market: 905
# of Times Listed: 4

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2009-05-07 for $235,000

MLS# 11062009      Google Maps


917 CAMPFIRE Cir
Rocklin, CA 95765
Total Loss: $10,100Percent Loss: 3.0%
Asking Price: $329,900
Bedrooms:4    Baths: 3    Sq. feet:2399

Listing History:
Down 16.5% from $394,990 On 2009-09-12
Down 3.0% from $340,000 On 2011-10-08

Days on market: 704
# of Times Listed: 3

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2009-11-24 for $340,000

MLS# 11071469      Google Maps


877 Lavastone Dr
Lincoln, CA 95648
Total Loss: $8,235Percent Loss: 2.9%
Asking Price: $279,400
Bedrooms:4    Baths: 2    Sq. feet:2707

Listing History:
Up 1.6% from $274,900 On 2010-09-18

Days on market: 236
# of Times Listed: 3

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2004-01-16 for $360,500
Sold on 2011-03-07 for $287,635
Sold on 2011-03-07 for $287,635
Sold on 2011-03-07 for $287,635

MLS# 11075604      Google Maps


3635 Sapphire Dr
Auburn, CA 95602
Total Loss: $8,000Percent Loss: 14.0%
Asking Price: $49,000
Bedrooms:2    Baths: 1    Sq. feet:922
Days on market: 1130
# of Times Listed: 2

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2003-12-31 for $30,000
Sold on 2004-03-31 for $102,500
Sold on 2008-09-24 for $57,000

MLS# 11061661      Google Maps


8120 Redwood Ln
Granite Bay, CA 95746
Total Loss: $7,150Percent Loss: 0.8%
Asking Price: $842,000
Bedrooms:5    Baths: 3    Sq. feet:3359

Listing History:
Up 10.8% from $759,900 On 2008-07-26

Days on market: 1264
# of Times Listed: 3

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2008-05-13 for $849,150

MLS# 11073390      Google Maps


6222 Lonetree Blvd
Rocklin, CA 95765
Total Loss: $5,501Percent Loss: 2.6%
Asking Price: $208,999
Bedrooms:4    Baths: 3    Sq. feet:1771

Listing History:
Down 3.7% from $217,000 On 2011-07-16
Down 1.4% from $212,000 On 2011-07-23

Days on market: 799
# of Times Listed: 2

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2009-08-21 for $214,500

MLS# 11049961      Google Maps


5519 Ivywood Ct
Foresthill, CA 95631
Total Loss: $5,000Percent Loss: 1.2%
Asking Price: $410,000
Bedrooms:5    Baths: 3    Sq. feet:3528

Listing History:
Down 48.1% from $789,900 On 2007-11-03
Down 43.8% from $729,000 On 2008-01-12
Down 33.9% from $620,000 On 2008-09-13
Down 12.6% from $469,000 On 2009-04-25
Down 4.4% from $429,000 On 2009-05-23
Down 8.7% from $449,000 On 2010-09-18
Down 7.4% from $443,000 On 2011-02-19
Down 5.7% from $435,000 On 2011-04-30
Up 2.6% from $399,450 On 2011-06-18

Days on market: 828
# of Times Listed: 6

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2009-07-23 for $415,000

MLS# 11067545      Google Maps


904 Farm House Ln
Rocklin, CA 95765
Total Loss: $4,100Percent Loss: 1.0%
Asking Price: $415,900
Bedrooms:4    Baths: 3    Sq. feet:3469

Listing History:
Down 5.5% from $439,900 On 2011-07-23

Days on market: 638
# of Times Listed: 2

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2010-01-29 for $420,000

MLS# 11053668      Google Maps


2008 Peridot St
Roseville, CA 95678
Total Loss: $1,499Percent Loss: 0.6%
Asking Price: $237,500
Bedrooms:3    Baths: 3    Sq. feet:1488

Listing History:
Down 5.0% from $249,900 On 2011-09-03

Days on market: 239
# of Times Listed: 2

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2011-03-04 for $238,999
Sold on 2011-03-04 for $238,999
Sold on 2011-03-04 for $238,999

MLS# 11063219      Google Maps


3675 Galena Dr
Auburn, CA 95602
Total Loss: $1,000Percent Loss: 1.7%
Asking Price: $59,000
Bedrooms:2    Baths: 1    Sq. feet:840

Listing History:
Up 22.2% from $48,300 On 2009-12-26
Down 13.9% from $68,500 On 2010-03-13
Down 1.5% from $59,900 On 2010-03-27

Days on market: 557
# of Times Listed: 4

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2004-04-19 for $128,000
Sold on 2010-04-20 for $60,000

MLS# 11074582      Google Maps


576 Sawka Dr
Auburn, CA 95603
Total Loss: $450Percent Loss: 0.1%
Asking Price: $379,800
Bedrooms:4    Baths: 3    Sq. feet:3145

Listing History:
Down 9.4% from $419,000 On 2011-07-23
Down 2.5% from $389,500 On 2011-08-20

Days on market: 505
# of Times Listed: 2

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2004-10-08 for $499,000
Sold on 2010-06-11 for $380,250

MLS# 11052205      Google Maps


2127 Celtic Dr
Lincoln, CA 95648
Total Loss: $395Percent Loss: 0.2%
Asking Price: $260,000
Bedrooms:4    Baths: 3    Sq. feet:2999
Days on market: 668
# of Times Listed: 2

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2005-03-02 for $500,000
Sold on 2009-12-30 for $260,395

MLS# 11070854      Google Maps


313 SAWTELL Rd
Roseville, CA 95678
Total Loss: $100Percent Loss: 0.1%
Asking Price: $189,900
Bedrooms:3    Baths: 2    Sq. feet:1329

Listing History:
Down 47.0% from $358,000 On 2006-04-21
Down 45.7% from $349,500 On 2006-05-25
Down 41.0% from $322,000 On 2006-06-09
Down 42.1% from $328,000 On 2006-06-16
Down 41.0% from $322,000 On 2006-07-15
Down 23.7% from $249,000 On 2008-03-15
Down 4.6% from $199,000 On 2008-06-21
Up 6.1% from $179,000 On 2008-08-16
Down 5.0% from $199,900 On 2010-04-03

Days on market: 1079
# of Times Listed: 7

Previous Sales:
Sold on 2006-08-21 for $320,000
Sold on 2008-11-14 for $190,000

MLS# 11055082      Google Maps

Total 85 in Placer County
Sum of Losses: $10,101,525

No comments :